In May 2019, Williams was sentenced to five years of probation each for the charges of insurance fraud and false statements and 12 months of probation for the false report of a crime charge. Superior Court Judge Clint Bearden made the sentences run concurrently, resulting in Williams needing to serve five years of probation total. Bearden also gave Williams a $5,000 fine and 120 hours of community service. On December 18, 2018, Hall County authorities charged Williams with insurance fraud, making a false statement, and false report of a crime. The charges related to a burglary that Williams reported in May 2018. Williams said $300,000 worth of computer servers were stolen from his campaign office. He was accused of lying to a Georgia Bureau of Investigation agent. In January 2019, Williams pleaded not guilty to the charges.

On December 18, 2018, Hall County authorities charged Williams with insurance fraud, making a false statement, and false report of a crime. The charges related to a burglary that Williams reported in May 2018. Williams said $300,000 worth of computer servers were stolen from his campaign office. He was accused of lying to a Georgia Bureau of Investigation agent. In January 2019, Williams pleaded not guilty to the charges. In May 2019, Williams was sentenced to five years of probation each for the charges of insurance fraud and false statements and 12 months of probation for the false report of a crime charge. Superior Court Judge Clint Bearden made the sentences run concurrently, resulting in Williams needing to serve five years of probation total. Bearden also gave Williams a $5,000 fine and 120 hours of community service.